Page MenuHomePureOS Tracker

Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliantGoal
ActivePublic

Watchers

  • This project does not have any watchers.

Details

Description

All copyright-protected files must be licensed in compliance with FSF guidelines.

NB! This may imply compliance with Debian guidelines too, but not in all cases.

We (PureOS developers) might locate or forward tasks here upstream as user-tagged Debian bugreports.

Recent Activity

Jun 12 2021

jonas.smedegaard lowered the priority of T57: [multiple issues] chromium from Freedom Issue to Low.

This is a meta-issue tracking a bundle of issues, and as such is not in itself a Freedom issue (that it identified for each unblundled issue). Lowering priority accordingly.

Jun 12 2021, 04:14

May 28 2021

jonas.smedegaard added a comment to T57: [multiple issues] chromium.

@adfeno I notice you mention lack of help examining, and also that you rely on licensecheck for your examination.

May 28 2021, 00:32

Feb 14 2021

jonas.smedegaard claimed T57: [multiple issues] chromium.
Feb 14 2021, 02:32
jonas.smedegaard renamed T57: [multiple issues] chromium from [FREEDOM ISSUE] chromium to [multiple issues] chromium.
Feb 14 2021, 02:31

Aug 13 2019

jonas.smedegaard added a comment to T57: [multiple issues] chromium.

@EchedeyLR https://packages.debian.org/source/testing/chromium

Aug 13 2019, 00:45

Aug 12 2019

EchedeyLR added a comment to T57: [multiple issues] chromium.

@mak Please stop block chromium - it does not contain non-free code and is no longer unclear about licensing.

Aug 12 2019, 17:44

Jul 8 2019

adfeno added a comment to T57: [multiple issues] chromium.

Also see https://directory.fsf.org/wiki/Review:Chromium-REV-ID-1 or https://directory.fsf.org/wiki/Talk:Chromium (the first link might be moved to the last one). Iridium Browser suffers from the same issues (this is described in the references). Also as described there, none of the lists is exhaustive, as we/volunteers from FSD lack some contributors specific for this issue.

Jul 8 2019, 02:29

Jul 2 2019

jonas.smedegaard added a comment to T57: [multiple issues] chromium.

@EchedeyLR Thanks for investigating. Please however report any concrete findings as separate issues.

Jul 2 2019, 10:30
EchedeyLR added a comment to T57: [multiple issues] chromium.

I think there is still a similar problem with Chromium like https://tracker.pureos.net/T663 due to Google dependence/promotion.

Jul 2 2019, 10:11
mak added a comment to T57: [multiple issues] chromium.

@mak Please stop block chromium - it does not contain non-free code and is no longer unclear about licensing.

Jul 2 2019, 09:51
EchedeyLR added a comment to T57: [multiple issues] chromium.

If I remember, Chromium is not packaged on Trisquel due to more problems but I am not sure.

Jul 2 2019, 09:45
jonas.smedegaard reopened T57: [multiple issues] chromium as "Open".

@mak Please stop block chromium - it does not contain non-free code and is no longer unclear about licensing.

Jul 2 2019, 05:43

Dec 18 2018

jonas.smedegaard added a subtask for T57: [multiple issues] chromium: T241: chromium - promotes non-free NVIDIA driver via (embedded copy of) libxnvctrl.
Dec 18 2018, 14:59

Aug 25 2018

mak closed T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF as Resolved.

I don't think re-purposing this old bug for a blacklist removal request is a good idea - I was actually a bit confused to me to see seeing the bug appear again with this title...

Aug 25 2018, 19:42 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant

Jun 18 2018

jonas.smedegaard lowered the priority of T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF from Freedom Issue to Low.

This is no longer a freedom-issue, just cleanup internally...

Jun 18 2018, 07:00 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard reopened T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF as "Open".

Please drop blocking from Debian: Package has been dropped as obsolete now: See https://bugs.debian.org/874575

Jun 18 2018, 06:57 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant

Apr 5 2018

mak closed T57: [multiple issues] chromium as Resolved.

@zlatan.todoric LibreOffice build-depends on chromium, so this will be quite annoying.
Package is removed from PureOS now, but we will need to find a solution for LO...

Apr 5 2018, 15:27

Mar 25 2018

zlatan.todoric reassigned T57: [multiple issues] chromium from hema.prathaban to mak.

@mak remove and block from re-entering the chromium package from archive as GNU-libre ML is pointing this out.

Mar 25 2018, 02:44

Nov 10 2017

jonas.smedegaard renamed Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant from Freedom-harm: license not GNU-compliant to Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant.
Nov 10 2017, 06:08
jonas.smedegaard renamed Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant from FSF-compliant license to Freedom-harm: license not GNU-compliant.
Nov 10 2017, 06:08
jonas.smedegaard changed the status of T49: cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF from Resolved to Invalid.

Changing status to "invalid", more appropriate for the task as a whole (arguably I should've created a subtask for the package removal which is indeed "done" by now).

Nov 10 2017, 05:57 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant

Nov 9 2017

mak closed T49: cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF as Resolved.

Done

Nov 9 2017, 21:51 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard reopened T49: cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF as "Open".
Nov 9 2017, 21:23 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard reassigned T49: cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF from jonas.smedegaard to mak.

Please drop derived cron package: There is no need for deriving from Debian (issue is bogus).

Nov 9 2017, 21:22 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard changed the status of T49: cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF from Resolved to Invalid.

This issue is bogus: It is correct for metadata to describe license as Artistic, but code itself is licensed "same as Perl" which means dual-licensing as _either_ Artistic or GPL-1+.

Nov 9 2017, 21:05 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant

Oct 26 2017

mak closed T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF as Resolved.
Will remove the following packages from landing:
Oct 26 2017, 15:01 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
mak closed T62: simutrans - license considered "too vague" by FSF as Resolved.
Will remove the following packages from landing:
Oct 26 2017, 14:56 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard changed the visibility for Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant.
Oct 26 2017, 12:39
jonas.smedegaard reassigned T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF from jonas.smedegaard to mak.

@mak Please block angband-doc from entering PureOS.

Oct 26 2017, 12:07 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant

Oct 25 2017

jonas.smedegaard renamed T62: simutrans - license considered "too vague" by FSF from [FREEDOM ISSUE] simutrans - license considered "too vague" by FSF to simutrans - license considered "too vague" by FSF.
Oct 25 2017, 05:01 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard added a comment to T62: simutrans - license considered "too vague" by FSF.

@mak please block simutrans, simutrans-pak128.britain, and simutrans-pak64,

Oct 25 2017, 04:51 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant

Oct 24 2017

jonas.smedegaard added a comment to T62: simutrans - license considered "too vague" by FSF.

@mak Ping!

Oct 24 2017, 16:38 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard edited projects for T62: simutrans - license considered "too vague" by FSF, added: Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant; removed Freedom.
Oct 24 2017, 16:37 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard edited projects for T57: [multiple issues] chromium, added: Freedom-harm: downloads nonfree code, Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant; removed Freedom.
Oct 24 2017, 16:33
jonas.smedegaard removed a parent task for T49: cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF: T234: nil.
Oct 24 2017, 06:04 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard renamed T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF from [FREEDOM ISSUE] angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF to angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF.
Oct 24 2017, 04:59 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard renamed T49: cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF from [FREEDOM ISSUE] cron - contain a file licensed too vaguely for FSF to cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF.
Oct 24 2017, 04:59 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard edited projects for T49: cron - contains a file licensed too vaguely for FSF, added: Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant; removed Freedom.
Oct 24 2017, 04:56 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard removed a project from T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF: Freedom (FSF-compliant license).
Oct 24 2017, 04:34 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard edited projects for T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF, added: Freedom (FSF-compliant license); removed Freedom (DFSG-compliant license).
Oct 24 2017, 04:33 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard added a project to T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF: Freedom (DFSG-compliant license).
Oct 24 2017, 04:32 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard edited projects for T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF, added: Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant; removed Freedom.
Oct 24 2017, 04:31 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard added a comment to T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF.

test

Oct 24 2017, 04:29 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard edited projects for T71: angband-doc - license (of packaging?) too vague for FSF, added: Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant; removed Freedom (FSF-compliant license).
Oct 24 2017, 04:27 · Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant
jonas.smedegaard renamed Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant from nil to FSF-compliant license.
Oct 24 2017, 04:25
jonas.smedegaard activated Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant.
Oct 24 2017, 04:24
jonas.smedegaard renamed Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant from Freedom (FSF-compliant license) to nil.
Oct 24 2017, 03:29
jonas.smedegaard set the color for Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant to Red.
Oct 24 2017, 03:28
jonas.smedegaard archived Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant.
Oct 24 2017, 03:27
jonas.smedegaard set the icon for Freedom-harm: license not FSF-compliant to Goal.
Oct 24 2017, 03:18