Page MenuHomePureOS Tracker

purebrowser - default search engine is not perfect
Open, LowPublic

Description

We want PureBrowser to offer the perfect search engine by default.

Perfectly respecting user privacy.
Perfectly using Free software, both at user-facing and all other parts.
Perfectly decentralized.
Perfectly secured against code injection, filter-bubbling, and any other threats.

Currently (2019-01-07) we offer DuckDuckGo, hinting than vendor is Debian.

Most popular (according to Alexa) multi-lingual and english-only web search engines:

  • Google
  • Bing
  • Yahoo! (rank skewed by non-search uses)
  • Ask.com (Google proxy)
  • DuckDuckGo (Bing proxy)
  • Ecosia (Bing proxy)
  • Yandex
  • Qwant (Bing proxy)
  • WebCrawler (Bing proxy)
  • Searx (metacrawler)
  • Gigablast (only english)
  • Mojeek
  • Startpage.com (Google proxy)

Meta search engines:

  • Dogpile
  • Excite
  • Info.com
  • Mamma
  • Metacrawler
  • PCH Search and Win
  • Searx
  • Yippy

P2P search engines:

  • FAROO
  • Seeks
  • YaCy

NB! Please discuss details of single facets of perfection as separate issues, and link those as sub-issues to this one.

NB! Please discuss non-default options as separate issues, and link those as sub-issues to this one.

Event Timeline

jonas.smedegaard updated the task description. (Show Details)
guido added a subscriber: guido.Jun 3 2019, 00:54

The same thing came up realted to GNOME Web: https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/librem5-base/merge_requests/36 - phone and laptops should ship the same list (only exception I could see is a engine with super nice search results that doesn't work on mobile)

jonas.smedegaard updated the task description. (Show Details)
jonas.smedegaard updated the task description. (Show Details)

The Librem 5 team needs a GNOME Web that ships with a list of serach engines that work on mobile and has reasonable results. We need this in GNOME Web ASAP because we'll be shipping the phone in the next couple of months, so for us this is a high priority.

@jonas.smedegaard since you have much more knowledge in this space, if we had to pick one engine today that was best aligned with 1) our freedom philosophy, 2) ability to work on mobile (not sure what's different to make this work), 3) decent search results, 4) work with languages besides English..... what would your recommendation be? We of course don't have to pick one engine today, but it helps get an idea of what we might implement if there is no golden solution by the time we need to provide something before shipment.

DuckDuckGo.

It is not perfect but its features and its limitations are well known both to us and to our users.

I'm just a buyer but my specialty is in surveillance and privacy, currently finishing my master's in communication. I would recommend startpage as an alternative to DuckDuckGo.

https://www.startpage.com/

It is highly customizable, you can make it use EU servers and it also has an option to browse search results through a proxy server, uses POST VS GET for additional privacy and your settings can be saved without a cookie.

guido added a comment.Jun 4 2019, 00:31

Just as a data point: I am a daily startpage user but it has availability and performance problems. I switch to ddg every now and then when startpage does not respond but that is not something we want to put on our users (that's why I opted to merge the ddg patch for the moment).